Oracle announced flat license revenues for its fourth quarter, sending its shares down 9%, further fueling the arguments that Oracle is behind - the Wall Steer Jounal's CIO Journal headlined "Oracle Tilting at the Wrong Windmills" in its earnings follow up. Yet most analysts seem to ignore the point that as subscriptions in a quarter go up, licenses in the quarter go down. Oracle's license business is predominately on-premise, so faster growth in subscriptions will lead to decreased revenue in licenses. Kash Rangan, a Research Analyst at Bank of America Merrill Lynch, pointed out
Cloud apps wins could have depressed lic growth by 2-4%
On the May Q earnings call, Oracle reported 80 Fusion apps wins and 200
Customer Experience app wins. If we conservatively assume $0.25-$0.5mn
license equivalent per transaction, these deals alone would result in “underreporting” license revenue by $70mn--$140mn, or 2-4% license growth. As Oracle’s Cloud business continues to ramp, investors will have to start measuring new ARR and growth to more accurately credit Oracle for the gradual business model shift. Oracle’s Cloud subscription is already a $1B business and expected to grow at ~25% in FY14.
Oracle may (or may not) manage this "gradual business model shift" over time, and the law of large numbers makes growth rate comparisons to smaller vendors somewhat beside the point. Workday's 2013 revenue was only 273 million (with a loss of 119 million) and while salsforce.com is over 3 billion in revenue, the company is still not profitable (on a GAAP basis).
The big news last week revolved around Oracle's back-to-back announcements with salesforce.com and Microsoft. The salesforce.com-Oracle alliance has SFDC adopting Oracle technology for its cloud offerings, as well as replacing Workday applications with Oracle Fusion applications for HCM and Financials.
The Microsoft-Oracle enterprise partnership extends the Oracle stack to Microsoft Azure, the Microsoft cloud platform. (Microsoft apparently will continue to run SAP).
Both of these alliances bring historically fierce competitors together, and while press releases don't run (or integrate) software, there is a lot more here than promises.
Oracle announced similar agreements with Amazon and NetSuite.
This was a very good week for Oracle. And for Oracle customers and partners.